The news, 365 days behind — on purpose Delayed live · replaying 2025

One Year Ago.AI

Remember how fast this is.

17MAR2024replayed
one year on
open weightsxAI

xAI releases Grok-1 as open-weight model on GitHub

The 314-billion-parameter model is now available under Apache 2.0 license, though only as raw base weights without training data or instruction tuning.

xAI today published the weights for Grok-1, the 314-billion-parameter mixture-of-experts model, under an Apache 2.0 license on GitHub. The release includes JAX code for loading and inference, along with a torrent link for the checkpoint.

The model uses eight experts with two active per token, a 64-layer architecture, and a context window of 8,192 tokens. However, the release is limited to raw base weights without instruction tuning or training data. The repository’s README explicitly states the implementation ‘is not efficient’ and requires ‘a machine with enough GPU memory.’

On Hacker News, where the announcement drew 1,170 points and 419 comments, the reception was mixed. Several commenters noted that while the parameter count makes Grok-1 the largest open-weight model yet, smaller models like Mixtral 8x7B reportedly outperform it on many metrics. The debate quickly turned to semantics: users argued whether ‘open weights’ qualifies as open source, with one commenter calling it ‘like calling a binary open source because you can download it.’ Others pointed out that without training data, fine-tuning risks catastrophic forgetting.

For now, the weights are out, but the training data remains behind closed doors.

H
HN user extheat

Noted that at 8x86B, it looks like the largest open model yet by far.

H
HN user swalsh

Argued that the model's comparatively poor performance relative to smaller models highlights the importance of fine-tuning.

H
HN user lukan

Noted that the model's comparatively poor performance relative to smaller models may also highlight the importance of training data quality.

H
HN user llm_trw

Criticized the release as 'open weight' rather than truly open source, comparing it to distributing binaries without source code.

One year later — open only if you can handle spoilers

Grok-1 never became a widely used open model; its size made it impractical for most researchers, and subsequent fine-tuned versions (like Grok-2) remained proprietary. The release did, however, fuel the ongoing debate about what 'open' means in AI, a discussion that continued as other large labs adopted similar weight-only releases.

Replay thisPost on XRedditHNLinkedIn

The Weekly Replay · free by email

This week, one year ago — every Sunday.

One email each Sunday: the week's replayed AI news, with the one-year-later annotations included. Written like it's breaking — dated like it isn't.

Free · double opt-in · unsubscribe anytime · privacy